Nations Championship, Northern Leg 2026, Week 2

 Week two of the Northern Leg brings us the pool match that everyone has been waiting for this month: France v South Africa. There are a bunch of other matches too, Scotland and Australia are both hurting and looking to improve, against Wales the AB have put out a B-side which will still probably win but it could be interesting, as the Boks found out in Australia.

On to the reviews.

France v South Africa

Before the game, I'd written this off. France had a long, deep injury list, and whilst it's true that South Africa were not at 100%, for them missing a prop and a lock is a case of opening the cupboard and picking which of the next 500 they've got tucked away to choose. Whilst Hooker is young and not like-for-like, he's a great replacement for Kolbe. Meanwhile, France's injury list meant they played Lucu in the 9 shirt (not an issue) and Dupont in the 10 shirt (which he has done for his club), because they're missing Ntamack, Jalibert, Hastoy and Ramos, their top four choices with test experience. All three rows of their pack were rearranged, their half-backs, their centres and their back three. Aldritt, whose international career had appeared to be over, not selected for a year, had been recalled as emergency cover in the back row. None of this is ideal when you're playing the current world #1. Add in a warmup injury to Marchand and yet more disruption and it's even worse.

Rassie was up to his old tricks, deciding to swap his announced starting and bench front rows an hour or two before the match started. 

Normally, if you were to write a mixed team after a close match like this, picking the best player in each position, you'd get a weird mix of colours. Each unit would, most likely, have one from here, one from there, and those with three players, would have a spare. If I were to do that for this game, that would be true for the back row, PSDT was great, as always, but the French back row edged the battle otherwise. In the front row, Mauvaka is unlucky (he would probably be on the bench if I picked a 23) but the SA 1-3 would be a complete unit. I think the second row would be one of each, although if you picked an all SA second row I wouldn't call you crazy. And every single back would wear blue. Hooker and Feinberg-Mngomezulu can count themselves a bit unlucky in that, they were both good, but the French backs were dominant and those two don't quite make the grade, the others aren't close. (Lucu actually played about 80% of the time at 10, despite the shirt numbers, I'm considering SFM against Lucu, not against POTM Dupont).

They say in rugby, it's the forwards that win matches, the backs decide by how much. This game was the counter-example to that. Certainly at scrum time, the Boks were all over Les Bleus - they got at least ten penalties there, and only 14 in total. Lineouts were more even, but South Africa successfully stole I think every throw on their own five metre line that France had. That said, around the park, the forward battle was much closer. But the South African backs were not looking after the pill, the forwards in the loose were a bit guilty of this too, and that aphorism proved more important during this game. The kicking from hand had blemishes on both sides, Lucu and Gourges (when Lucu was sin-binned), plus Sacha FM all missed kicks to the corner for example, kicking it dead. But generally speaking, the French tactical kicking was good-to-excellent, the South African kicking rarely reached good. Arguably this match, where the set pieces were so one-sided, but not decisive, and the kicking game was so one-sided the other way underlines a shift in the game. 

Whilst it's not an aphorism, yet, it's fair to say that common knowledge would hold that beating this team, like beating the All Blacks in days gone by, requires some luck. France had that. There was a hard pass that smacked Gourges in the face, went forwards from that and was grounded by a very alert Attisogbe. You can't knock on with your head, so try. Luck. On the other side, just as the clock turned red for half-time, it looked like Arendse had scored a try off a lineout. But he'd crept offside, no try. Lack of discipline by him (and typical of the SA backs throughout), but lucky for France. 

There is a saying in sport that you make your own luck. The French definitely did that. For example, PSDT crossed the line, and the hustle, in the end from Dupont who got under the ball, but from about three others who were scraping for every millimetre against what looked like the whole Bok pack and slowed him down enough that Dupont could get there at the last second to deny the try. They also poached turnovers at critical times and destroyed attacking momentum repeatedly.

This might have been a low-scoring game in the end, but it was gripping throughout. Broadly speaking, for the first 50 minutes the French were making chances and the South Africans were fighting like hell to keep them out. For the last 30 that was reversed. The stats say France played about evenly in every part of the field, the SA's played more between halfway and the French 22 than everywhere else put together. But it felt like the game was only played in each other’s red zone. 

Whilst the ultimate difference in the points came down to Libbok missing a conversion and Lucu kicking all of his, if Arendse had stayed onside, if PSDT hadn't been held up, it would have been different.

A quick word for the crowd. There may have been some South Africans present. But the French members of it were loud, partisan, and loved seeing the French take it to the South Africans. For 50 minutes it was pretty much one way and a happy crowd. For the last 30 it was a much more nervous group, but they rallied and were singing La Marseillaise at the top of their lungs to try, and ultimately succeed, in supporting their team. It was glorious to see and hear.

France are now on top of the NH section of competition and looking forwards to Argentina. South Africa have not yet ceded top spot, but will assuming New Zealand beat Wales and that probably means NZ v France for the glory in a couple of weeks.

Italy v Argentina

It’s not really fair to directly compare this match to the previous one. If you have 1v4 in the world then 8v11 you should expect a decline in quality. Add to that the fact that Argentina appointed Shaun Edwards as defence coach recently and he’s basically at the end of his first full week and it’s fair to describe them as a team in transition. It’s equally fair to say that you could see moments of his defensive style coming through from Los Pumas already, when they’ve had a year with him, they’ll be much better. 

But apart from that, this was a game of errors. Now, every team and every player makes mistakes. I highlighted Feinberg-Mngomezulu's substandard kicking for example, and glossed over about 15 turnovers lost from each side in yesterday’s match. That was because, by and large, they were caused by the pressure of the game. It’s easy saying these are elite rugby players, they should be able to catch and pass - they can and do - but it’s a lot harder doing either of those if you have 150 kg of prop hitting you as you try and do it! Unlike that game, and much more like Australia last week, these two teams tended to make those errors without the pressure, and then make more with pressure, and then manufacture turnovers too. 

Where yesterday’s match was pulsing and felt like it was only played in each other’s 22, this was a drag and felt more like it was only played between the 10m lines. That’s wrong, there were five tries, heroic turnovers on the 5m line and more, but it’s how the match felt. 

In the end, Argentina had slightly fewer moments when they blew their chances and staggered to a 19-14 victory. 

Wales v New Zealand

Like every good Welsh rugby fan, 1953 is engraved in my heart as the last time we beat the All Blacks. This time, as a team that is undeniably improving from the depths it had sunk to, but equally has a long way to go to reach the heights that feel natural and comfortable - competing to be the top of the Six Nations, and expecting at least a semifinal at the RWC - is a multi-year project for us. Australia is too soon, but there is hope for the USA. 

The prematch included a haka, of course. But the lighting people at the Principality Stadium decided to get in on the act. The All Blacks were isolated in a patch of light, surrounded by darkness, which we’ve seen before, but is nice and dramatic. New this time was the red backlighting for the Welsh, which definitely added something to the occasion, and the Welsh flag on the advertising scroller around the edge of the upper tier. 

In last week’s review I wrote that I wanted a performance from Wales, but even with a weakened team, I expected the All Blacks to win this one. I certainly got a performance. Wales roared out to a 14-0 lead within six minutes. By halftime NZ had pegged it back to 21-all and although Wales looked up for the fight, it was noticeable that they put effort in to score their tries whilst the AB seemed to gain entry to the 22 and score quickly. I wasn’t letting myself hope - I’ve seen the AB last 20 minutes too often to trust Wales. 

In the second half, Wales scored twice more, quickly, after 43 and 48 minutes. Then came the longest half an hour of my life. New Zealand scored a few minutes later, leaving the score at 35-28 to Wales, and that was an end to the scoring. New Zealand basically camped in the Welsh 22, almost on the Welsh 5m line. Lots of tackles†, but turnovers and balls held up over the line, honestly so many I lost count. (Apparently it was only three, if you told me it was 300, and all the Welsh players were wearing Spartan armour, I'd believe you.) Through the last ten minutes the commentator was counting down the minutes. For the last three, he was counting down every 30s. I’ve never seen that before, but it caught the atmosphere of the occasion, the feeling in the crowd, and me at home. 

† I said lots of tackles, but whilst the exact number varies a little, it's around 346/348 depending on which source you use. They also had a 90% success rate. The previous record, also held by Wales, was in the 2023 RWC, and that was 241. For another comparison, the French, who I think most commentators would agree put up a staunch defence for the last 30 minutes, "only" made 175 tackles. Wales basically made twice as many as that! Daf Jenkins made 40 individual tackles, and Elias, who came on with 20 minutes to go, as the All Blacks set up camp in the Welsh 22, made 20 tackles. First, that's one a minute, which is crazy, second, he would have been top tackler in France v South Africa, the day before, which is is also crazy.

I thought that the crowd at the Stade de France yesterday was loud. The Principality, with the roof closed? It was built for games like this, and even though it wasn’t full, the noise was incredible. As time went by, from about 60 minutes on, I started to believe more and more. First that a four try bp + losing bp was in reach, then a four try bp + two points for a draw. For the last five minutes it was more of a belief that we’d win. 

It deserves to be said that this was not the full-fat All Blacks. The fast start might have been predictable, but it just kept going, which was not. The last 20 minute surge manifested but… the Welsh believed that they were good enough and they made about a million tackles, held the ball up about a dozen times and rewrote the history books. 

I normally quote points per entry into the 22 and I haven’t so far. Just after they scored their fourth try, I happened to check the stats. New Zealand had entered the Welsh 22 six times, that’s 4.7 points per entry. They ended up with 16 entries and 1.8 points per entry. That’s ten entries in the last 20+ minutes with no points! By comparison, Wales had 10 total entries and 35 points, 3.5 points per entry, and a perfectly decent return. Whilst we're talking stats, last week I mentioned I'd put Tomos Williams in my list of world class scrum halves. Wales scored five tries. He personally scored one and got four assists. 

For the All Blacks, in the grand scheme of things, they have still edged above SA on the SH table, but only by one point instead of four. Next weekend's results are more important, but the Kiwis are still in the driver’s seat. 

For Wales, this result is probably going to be seminal. When sports historians look at the history of a successful team under a given coach, there’s usually a result vaguely like this. A match that you were supposed to lose, possibly surrounded by loses, but that gives the players something to look back on and build from. Good teams have a habit of winning, enough players who have been in those tough situations before and come through it, and obviously that habit takes time to build up. But this Welsh 23 has the memory of being the first Welsh team to beat the All Blacks in 73 years. They remember scoring those tries, digging deep to defend for 20 minutes and all the rest of it. They know they can do it, and it gets easier to do it again. Eventually it becomes a habit, you become willing and able to do it every week. And that makes you a top four team.

Obviously most of this is about Wales. I’m not sure what Rennie will extract from this. To my eyes, most or all of the established names in black were fine, the new faces, not so much. Mo'unga showed that, after three years in Japan, he’s not up to speed for test rugby, clearly behind Love and DMac. That might change after a full season of SR of course. Ratimer does not really cut the mustard at 9 either. Almost certainly all of these players are good with a regular AB starter on either side of them, as injury cover, but they’re not there yet. They might be after the RWC. 

After letting these reviews bubble for a couple of days on these, I can’t decide whether this match or the France v South Africa match is the best of the year. This result was definitely the most surprising; I expected South Africa to win, but it wasn’t a shock for France to win that, they’ve done so within the last few years, within Rassie's reign. At 73 years we're running into “not within living memory” territory for the last time Wales beat New Zealand. But on a wider scale, I don’t care: two excellent games on successive days, what a brilliant weekend!

England v Japan

This match started in the best possible way for England and the worst possible way for Japan. A try to Joseph after five minutes and a 20 minute red card to Hockings at the same time, for a bad tackle in the build up to the try. If that had been a Welsh player shown red, I might have grumbled, but it was the right call.

By the time Japan were up back up to 15, England had scored five more tries and had essentially broken the Brave Blossoms spirit. They were more now the Wilting Leaves. 

England would go on to score 13 tries from 21 entries at 3.7 points per entry. For such a dominant performance you can quibble that's too low. England lost the ball 12 times and had it pilfered 5. These seem like decent numbers in the grand scheme of things, but remember they were pretty much in total control of this game. Wales lost the ball seven times and, against a Kiwi team who were much more of a threat, had it pilfered seven times. Both France and South Africa, in what was a far more intense game, had 16 turnovers lost, due to the massive pressure - England were barely ever under pressure and lost the pill nearly as often. Given their dominance, those numbers are not all that good. 

Ireland v Fiji

The final score for this game reads 43-15 and looks like a comfortable win for Ireland. However, for about five minutes in the first half, Fiji were ahead, and Ireland only eked out a lead with ten to go in the half, a lead that they managed to keep, initially just, then increasingly easily, aided by a yellow card during which period they scored 14 points.

Ireland scored at 3.1 points per entry from their 14 entries, Fiji at only 0.9 points per entry from their 16 entries. That's a decent attack and a strong defence from the Irish over the whole game. Although it says something about the Irish system that the Fijians got into their 22 that often.

Really this game should be compared to the French performance against Fiji last week. The French put out a young side to gain some experience. The Irish put out pretty much their full-strength squad. Those kiddies kept the Fijians at bay until the last few minutes, and scored more tries than the full Irish team. Worrying? Not to me. But for Farrell? Probably moreso. It wasn’t a great performance to put aside a weak team. Fiji have had an extra week together of course, but we should have expected something closer to the England v Japan result than this. 

I want to comment on the refereeing. I’m not going to say it was biased, I’m sure I could go back through the match and find decisions I disagree with against the Irish. But three huge ones stand out, for me, against the Fijians. 

  1. At about the 20 minute mark, Fiji scored a try and the TMO called it back for a knock on. Eventually the referee agreed. Now, that eventually is important, as is the wording of the laws about clear and obvious errors. It wasn’t clear to me, to any non-Irish commentator on the night, and apparently not to the referee either. But eventually he gave up, apparently to shut the TMO up. 
  2. In the second half, a Fijian player was shown yellow for a high tackle with a swinging arm. The problem? The Irish player had both been tackled and was diving for the try line. If he was upright, it hits him in the thighs. I am not saying it wasn’t an arm to the head, but fuck there was a lot of mitigation that wasn’t applied to the decision. 
  3. Prendergast has been cited for a hip-drop tackle. That means in the opinion of the citing officer his offence reached the red card threshold. Both the referee and the TMO missed it. Now, I accept that both referees and TMOs are human and make mistakes, but the Fijian player was injured in the tackle and required attention. The game actually stopped because of it. Given this is a new, high-priority law, and it was a tackle from behind with a stoppage, they might have thought "Oh, I should check that, just in case?" Apparently not. I'm not clear on the wording of the laws and how it's applied yet - I've read the updated law 9.13 but it's the application that matters - but even if they'd looked on the day and decided on a yellow card, that's a huge difference in the match.

Every game has rough decisions, but those three felt like they had a huge impact on the game. And all against Fiji.

Scotland v Australia

This was a match between two teams with a lot to prove after last week’s performances. It’s fair to say that the Wallabies had more to prove than the Scots, a medium loss to the #2 team in the world is not terrible, even if you were closer last year, a shellacking by a team you’re close to in the rankings is bad. Losing to England might have been ok, but losing like that was unacceptable. 

The first half looked like a better version of Italy v Argentina; two teams desperate to win who needed to settle down and just play. It wasn’t as hard to watch at the game in Bologna, but both sides were guilty of doing what the Wallabies did last week, and running into crowds of defenders and just not making metres. Maybe not every single time, but often enough it was the dominant feature of the game. The half ended 12-5 to Scotland, I’m not quite sure how. 

This lack of willingness to play continued into the second half where nobody could score until the last five minutes. Scotland slotted a penalty to mean Australia had to score twice. It seemed unnecessary, they hadn’t looked like scoring since their early try. Just before the clock went red, the Wallabies scored undoubtedly the best try of the match and tried to run it from deep from the restart, but were tackled into touch. The Scottish fans might heave a sigh of relief but neither coach will be happy with this pile of crap. 

Off the Pitch

Rassie launched into a tirade against the citing procedure and that "they would find a way to get Prendergast off because it's the Northern Hemisphere." I'd like to suggest that the chocolate wheel of justicejudicial panel is weird and inconsistent in its processes everywhere, but calling them out like this was stupid. World Rugby agreed, at least with the stupidity part, and slapped him with a six game ban.

Prendergast was duly cleared…

Looking Ahead

Next week we have the final weekend of pool matches. The South Africa and New Zealand games will determine who ends up in first place in the Southern Hemisphere group for example. Unlike previous weeks, all the matches are on the Saturday, there are three pairs of matches. 

  • England v New Zealand. This looks like the match of the weekend. New Zealand will be hurting, it’s not really clear how good England are at the moment, they’ve bullied two poor teams. 
  • Scotland v Japan. Scotland ought to be better than Japan, but after today’s performance, who can tell?
  • Ireland v South Africa. As always it depends on who Rassie puts out. But Ireland haven’t looked really convincing and South Africa will be hurting. This could be a rehearsal for the following week. 
  • Italy v Fiji. This is a match with pride on the line for two poor teams. 
  • France v Argentina. France should win this comfortably and win the NH group at a canter. You can never be 100% sure, see Wales v All Blacks, but France have Jalibert returning and Argentina have been disappointing. 
  • Wales v Australia. This is a hard match to call. Australia have been poor so far. No one would blame Wales if they’re a bit flat after yesterday’s performance. There is no doubt that, if they play anywhere close to yesterday’s levels, Wales win this, and win it well. I can believe they’ll crash and lose it, but I wouldn’t blame them. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

TRC 2022 - Team of the Tournament

TRC round four and WRWC quarterfinals

The Rugby Championships 2022, weeks one and two